Project case study

Contractor performance review and dispute support

An independent review of contractor performance, followed by contract management support and expert advice through a contract dispute.

Introduction

Derbyshire Dales District Council’s waste collection service is delivered by an external contractor, under a contract that Nik had supported the Council to procure in 2018–20. Once the service was running, performance issues arose and a contract dispute followed. The Council needed an independent view of how the contractor was performing, and expert advice on its contractual position.

Nik was appointed as Lead Adviser to review the contractor’s performance, to support officers with day-to-day contract management, and to advise the Council through the dispute.

Project details

The Council’s waste collections contract was procured using the Competitive Procedure with Negotiation, with a payment mechanism that shares material price risk between the Council and its contractor.

The Council needed to understand how the contractor was performing against the contractual requirements, and where improvements were most needed. Nik’s review characterised the levels of performance and identified the key areas for improvement, and he then supported the Council as it worked through those issues, applied the contract’s mechanisms and dealt with the dispute.

The work identified the root causes of the issues, improved the quality of the service and resolved significant overpayments.

Recircle’s input

As Lead Adviser, Nik supported the Council across three linked areas: reviewing contractor performance, contract management and the contract dispute. The work included:

  • An independent review of the contractor’s performance against the contractual requirements, characterising performance levels and identifying the key areas for improvement
  • Supporting officers in presenting the findings of the review to Elected Members
  • Day-to-day contract management support, identifying the root causes of performance issues and working to resolve them
  • Support in applying the contractual mechanisms
  • Support in implementing variations to the contract
  • Commercial and contractual advice to officers through the contract dispute, including identifying overpayments for the service
  • Technical, commercial and strategic advice on the Council’s options, with the benefits and disbenefits of each
  • Regular meetings with senior officers, including the Chief Executive, and with Elected Members to assist decision-making

Outcomes

Root causes identifiedNik helped to identify the root causes of the issues and ensure they were resolved
Improved service qualityContractor performance was improved and the issues resolved
Financial recoverySignificant overpayments for the service were identified and resolved
Follow-on work

This work led to another Recircle project, in which Nik was appointed Lead Adviser to consider alternative options for commissioning the Council’s waste collection service.

Read the related case study: Commissioning options for waste collections →