Commissioning options for waste collections
An independent appraisal of how the Council should deliver its collection service in future, taken from options appraisal through to a costed feasibility study.

Introduction
Derbyshire Dales District Council’s waste and recycling collection service is delivered by an external contractor. Following performance issues with the contractor, and a contract dispute, the Council wanted to understand whether outsourcing was still the best way to deliver the service.
Nik was appointed as Lead Adviser to explore the Council’s commissioning options, and to set out the tasks, challenges, risks and costs of each, so that the Council could make informed decisions on its future service provision.
Project details
The work was delivered in two linked stages. The first was a commissioning options appraisal, which identified and assessed alternative commissioning options, including bringing the service in-house or through a Teckal company, alongside retaining the existing outsourced arrangement. Nik reported the findings to the Council in April 2022.
The second stage was a detailed feasibility study for moving the service to an in-house direct service organisation (DSO). It built a model of costs and delivery under each approach, benchmarked other local authorities, tested the market, and reviewed the implications of terminating the existing contract.
Recircle’s input
As Lead Adviser, Nik worked with the Council in two linked stages, each building on the last.
- Identifying and assessing alternative commissioning options, including bringing the service in-house or through a Teckal company
- Helping the Council understand the tasks, challenges, risks and relative costs of each option
- Reporting the findings to the Council in April 2022
- Building a model of the costs and delivery of the service under each commissioning approach
- Benchmarking against other local authorities
- Market engagement on dry recycling containers and fibres, and on management information systems
- Reviewing the implications of terminating the existing contract
- Setting out the transition tasks, risks and costs for the Council’s decision
Outcomes
This project followed Recircle’s earlier work reviewing the contractor’s performance and supporting the Council through a contract dispute.
Read the related case study: Contractor performance review and dispute support →
Legal, financial & investment
Local authorities & public bodies
Waste management companies