Project case study

Expert witness support on a residual waste processing procurement

Independent expert advice for two local authorities on a residual waste processing procurement subject to legal proceedings.

Introduction

Two local authorities were procuring a residual waste processing contract when legal proceedings were issued by a waste management contractor. The Councils needed independent, specialist expertise to help ensure the procurement was run in a fair and transparent manner with no bias towards any specific bidder or solution, and to advise on the waste technical and commercial matters that could influence the project.

Nik was appointed as Expert Witness, working alongside the Councils, their legal adviser and King’s Counsel.

Project details

The Councils needed to be able to show that the procurement was fair, transparent and technically well-founded. Nik carefully scrutinised procurement and contract documents to test this, including whether the procurement was set up to ensure fairness to all bidders and solutions.

Expert evidence of this kind depends on a thorough understanding of the waste market and waste processing technologies, and of pending legislative changes and how they may affect waste contracts, together with strong commercial judgement. It also requires detailed knowledge of the potential solutions, and of how they would be influenced by the structure of the procurement and the commercial positions adopted by the Councils.

Recircle’s input

Nik acted as Expert Witness for both Councils, working closely with them, their legal adviser and King’s Counsel. The work included:

  • Careful scrutiny of procurement and contract documents, to test that the procurement was fair and transparent, and set up to ensure fairness to all bidders and solutions
  • Expert support on the waste technical and commercial matters that could influence the project
  • Insight into residual waste processing technologies and capacity
  • Reviewing the key legislation shaping the procurement, including emissions trading, and how its impact could differ between UK-based and EU-based solutions

Outcomes

Two councils supportedon a residual waste processing procurement subject to legal proceedings
Independent, expert advicegrounded in market, technical and commercial knowledge
Procurement completedsuccessfully, despite the legal proceedings
Confidentiality

This engagement was confidential, so the clients are not named and details are limited.